What "Change" Is.........

For many, Obama's calls for 'change' are simply a masterful PR ploy packaged by a good-looking candidate seeking the support of an increasingly anxious electorate  

Many such critics are Democrats, and quite a few of them Hillary supporters.

In light of Obama's decision to forgo public financing after publicly suggesting that he would not do so, and ofcourse the FISA (in)decision that has so riled the blogosphere recently, many-and this includes sincere Obama supporters- are left to ask:

"Is this what he means by change?" or "So much for the new politics"

For longtime Obama supporters, who see his rise and candidacy as a historical moment as important as FDR's, we often take for granted that many Democrats simply do not have the deep and broad knowledge of this man, his particuarly unique view of politics, and what has brought him to this moment.

I believe it is important that Obama supporters, after this long and at times divisive primary, begin to lay bare for our fellow Democrats what Obama means by change and how this will transform our politics.

Before I do, several First Principles.

What changes does not mean, is simply a change of parties in Washington.  While that is certainly important, it is not our organizing principle.  Also, the change will not come from Obama himself, outside of favored legislation ofcourse, but from the American people.  He, nor any other politician, will not be a 'change agent'.  

This movement seeks not revolutionary change, but transformative change.  Our movement seeks to:

1. Broad and meaningful participation of average folks in our government.  American democracy needs more Americans.

2. Irrevocably breaking the hold of corporate special interests on our policy making apparatus.

3. Open up all major policy discussions(healthcare, enviromental policy, ie) at the Executive level to this more attentive and engaged electorate with the now on-guard 'interests' sitting literally and figuratively right next to each other.

4. Bathed in this light and openness, the 'interests' that block change on a variety of policy will be forced to make real concessions largely because the sheer number of Americans paying attention will force their hands.

5. Finally, our political and ideological opponents, who will block change by virtue of being simply opposed will be respected.  Republicans and conservatives are not evil, they are misguided.  And they more broadly benefit from the current system than does the Left. Respecting them, rather than smearing them and their supporters, will make it easier to pass important, progressive legislation.

This is what we mean by Change. This is the political dispensation we seek to create.  It is the Organizer's, rather than the Politicians, view of aquiring, harnessing, and marshalling Power.

Our current political culture is so riven by defensive and partisan rancor that it is impeding progress.  This must end. And this generation must end it.  Why continue to engage in the partisan death-battle if another option is possible?

Our frustrations of this past week, and much of the last 7 years, essentially boil down to a political culture that occurs in the dark and with a healthy assist from interests that block change.

Does anyone honestly believe, had the process been open and with the participation of the American people, we would be talking about FISA or enjoying universal health coverage?

When Barack says change doesn't happen from the 'top down, but the bottom up' he means it.  More importantly, he practiced and honed it.  First in the South Side, then in the Illionois Legislature, and then the US Senate.

This idea of power, our movement for change, and our desire for progress- to the cynical- may seem hopelessly naive.  

To those who believe this is so, evidence of what we are doing can be seen in our attainment of goals #1 and #2.  And I dare even suggest, dethroning the Clinton Machine in phase one of the movement- a hardened, battle-tested practioner in the Old Politics- as evidence as well.

Have Hope fellow Democrats, you are about to enjoy the next 8 years.  



Display:


Re: What "Change" Is......... (2.00 / 1)

So you came here to bash democrats?

Its people like you that make me really not like the democratic party that represents change from the Clinton years.

You have the fix for everything because you have done nothing.

Reminds me of a certain young presidential candidate from texas about 8 years ago...

Seems he was gonna bring a new kind of conservative that none of us were smart enough to understand just like you are bringing a new kind of liberal that the rest of us "battle-tested practioner in the Old Politics" just don't seem to be able to comprehend in your mind.

Meet the new boss same as the old boss...


by dtaylor2 on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 04:52:55 AM EST

Re: What "Change" Is......... (2.00 / 1)

The 'old politics' at some point probably made a whole lot of sense.  

But so too did the commonly held view that the world was flat.  A brave, Genevese sailor saught to prove otherwise, and the history of civilization changed as a result.

Is is not time to seriously address the internal threats to our experience in self-governance by marshalling a different and perhaps more effective means by which to aquire and wield power for progressive aims?

Why are you so comfortable with a model that has not led to any measurable and sustained change in the lives of the majority of the American people?

If it makes you feel good to attack me and the movement to which I am a part as somehow 'alien' to the Democratic Party you may do so.  But please try to do it in a spirit of respect, rather than hurling insults, untruths, and willful distortions.

It isn't becoming of you nor the participants of this blog.


by ChangeMatters on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 06:21:00 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: What "Change" Is......... (none / 0)

"Why are you so comfortable with a model that has not led to any measurable and sustained change in the lives of the majority of the American people?"

Are you serious?

How old were you in 1992?


by dtaylor2 on Tue Jun 24, 2008 at 01:44:07 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: What "Change" Is......... (none / 0)

Change means a lot of different things to different people. Let's see what other Obama supporter think change means to them.

Like your's though.


by devil on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 07:59:33 AM EST

Re: What "Change" Is......... (2.00 / 2)

I've done this political "stuff" for almost forty years. The wonderful thing about "change" is that it has absolutely no content:  like  beauty, it is in the eye of the beholder.  FDR was change, so were Harry Truman and Jimmy Carter; Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan - change.  Both Bushes - change. Stalin, Hitler, Churchill, DeGaulle - ALL change.
But what kind of change?
You have absolutely no evidence for your fairy tale description of change. Certainly nothing in OB's actions to date - emphasis on the word actions - because he has done what any candidate from the Chicago school of win at all costs politics would do, and little else.
Now, since he has virtually no record, OB's every action here on out will be bisected and dissected, analyzed and deconstructed to find out who the h--- he actually is.
At a certain point, childish marketeering phrases like "change you can believe in," "yes we can" and
"we are the people we've been waiting for" just won't cut it. They will get the collective "huh?'" they should have gotten all along.
And fanciful - and solipsistic - faux seals won't help.
Change - in the end - is just a six letter word.      
by M1513 on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 09:44:50 AM EST

Re: What "Change" Is......... (none / 0)

yep, my thoughts exactly.


by colebiancardi on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 09:45:41 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: What "Change" Is......... (2.00 / 2)

You pretty well nailed it.  Sadly we can be precise where imprecision is the accusation.  We can be conciliatory when bellicosity is received.  We can be erudite when all they hear is slogans.  We can outperform and out-campaign when inexperience is the watchword.

Some folks just don't get it.  Some folks just don't want to.  Some of them have posted in this thread.  They're not evil.  They're mostly skeptical.  That's fine, that's even healthy.  It's the folks who ascribe to Senator Obama the most nefarious of intentions that disgust me.  We don't get too much of that hereabouts anymore.

To those who lack faith in the man, I say this: keep an open mind.  It's not too much to ask.


by Reaper0Bot0 on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 09:55:04 AM EST

Re: What "Change" Is......... (2.00 / 1)

I don't get it . . . this whole "change" and "hope" meme.

I'll vote for Obama, of course.  

I don't know that there really is anything all that "new" here.  Despite the nice packaging, it looks more and more like same old same old (especially Nunn) but Obama's same old same old is so much better than McCain's same old same old that . . . well . . . it's a no-brainer.

Obama, of course.
Is this transformational and revolutionary and new?  Don't think so, but that would be nice.  Thing is, of course, that it doesn't have to be transformational and revolutionary to be one hell of a lot better.

Got my vote.


"If you don't care about everybody, you don't care about anybody." --Ethan Mordden
by prodigal on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 11:12:53 AM EST

Re: What "Change" Is......... (1.00 / 2)

Well if anyone had a backbone he would not get the nomination.


by orion1 on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 11:52:25 AM EST

Re: What "Change" Is......... (none / 0)

This diary makes a lot of good and fair observations.

Your five points are well-stated. I agree that these are the kinds of goals that motivate a lot of those who've supported the Obama campaign, and I suspect these goals are shared by many Americans.

What we've seen in Obama is the promise and potential to set in motion if not all at least some of these changes. His management style, his organization, and yes, his rhetoric to date have spoken to this very effectively. And that's why, I think, he's taken the nomination, and continues to poll so well, because these are the changes America wants.

Will Obama fulfill the hope he's offering? Surely not for those seeking instant gratification, because that's not what this is about.

It's about setting the wheels of change in motion. It's the first step, and sometimes the hardest part.


"This victory alone is not the change we seek -- it is only the chance for us to make that change." -- Nov. 4, 2008
by BobzCat on Sun Jun 22, 2008 at 12:56:09 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.